Theories · 1915 – Today
Testing General Relativity
From a solar eclipse in 1919 to the shadow of a black hole in 2019, a century of experiments has tried to break the theory. None has.
Mercury's Orbit (1915)
Mercury's elliptical orbit slowly swivels around the Sun. After accounting for the tug of every other planet, astronomers were left with a discrepancy of about 43 arcseconds per century that Newton's gravity could not explain. On 18 November 1915 Einstein calculated what his new theory predicted: 43 arcseconds. No adjustment was needed.
Starlight at an Eclipse (1919)
The completed 1915 theory predicted that starlight grazing the Sun (mass , radius ) would be deflected by an angle arcseconds. The stars near the Sun are only visible during a total eclipse. On 29 May 1919 two British expeditions, to Sobral in Brazil and the island of Príncipe off West Africa, photographed them. The results, announced in London on 6 November, favored Einstein, and made him famous around the world within days.
Einstein had published an earlier prediction of light bending in 1911 using the equivalence principle alone, before he knew that spatial geometry is also curved; that 1911 calculation gave half the full value ( arcseconds). A German expedition led by Erwin Finlay-Freundlich to the Crimea to test it during the August 1914 eclipse was arrested at the outbreak of the First World War—a stroke of historical luck for Einstein, who corrected the prediction to arcseconds in November 1915.
Clocks and Free Fall (1960 onward)
In 1960 Robert Pound and Glen Rebka measured the change in frequency of gamma rays climbing a 22.5-meter tower at Harvard, confirming that time runs faster higher up. In 2022 a team at JILA in Colorado detected the same gravitational redshift across a single millimeter, inside one cloud of ultracold strontium atoms. That same year, the final results from the MICROSCOPE satellite confirmed the weak equivalence principle—that different materials fall at the same rate in space—to about one part in .
Delayed Signals and Dragged Space
- Shapiro delay. Radar signals passing near the Sun take slightly longer than they would in flat space. Tracking the Cassini spacecraft in 2002 confirmed the prediction to about 0.002 percent.
- Frame dragging. A spinning mass twists spacetime around it. NASA's Gravity Probe B, launched in 2004, measured the effect of the rotating Earth on orbiting gyroscopes and found agreement with the theory, to within about 0.3 percent for the larger geodetic precession and about 19 percent for the tiny frame-dragging drift.
The Binary Pulsar (1974)
Russell Hulse and Joseph Taylor discovered two neutron stars orbiting each other. Over the following years the orbit shrank at the rate expected, to within a fraction of a percent, if the pair were losing energy as gravitational waves. It was the first evidence that the waves were real, and earned the 1993 Nobel Prize.
Gravitational Waves (2015)
On 14 September 2015 the two LIGO detectors recorded a ripple in spacetime from a pair of black holes merging about 1.3 billion light-years away. See Gravitational Waves.
The Shadow of a Black Hole (2019 & 2022)
The Event Horizon Telescope, a global array of radio observatories working as one Earth-sized instrument, released in 2019 the first image of a black hole, from data taken in 2017: the object at the center of the galaxy M87, 55 million light-years away, with the mass of 6.5 billion Suns. In May 2022 the collaboration released the image of Sagittarius A\, the four-million-solar-mass black hole at the center of our own Milky Way. Although M87\ and Sagittarius A\* differ in mass and size by more than a factor of 1,500, the ring diameters of both shadows matched general relativity's prediction.
The Scorecard
Every one of these tests could have failed. That is what makes them tests. Physicists keep looking for a discrepancy, because a crack in general relativity would be the first clue to whatever deeper theory lies beneath it.
Sources
- Stanford Gravity Probe B — mission status
- US National Science Foundation — first image of a black hole
- NIST — JILA atomic clocks measure general relativity at millimeter scale
- LIGO — detection of GW150914
- American Physical Society, Physics — The weight of light (Pound and Rebka)
- Bertotti, Iess and Tortora, Nature 425, 374 (2003) — the Cassini test
- Nobel Prize in Physics 1993 — press release
- Physics Today — Arch and scaffold: how Einstein found his field equations
- Trinity College Library, Cambridge — A century of relativity
- Smithsonian Magazine — the 1919 eclipse
- Lemos — Shadow of the Moon and general relativity
- Einstein, Annalen der Physik 340, 898 (1911) — On the influence of gravitation on the propagation of light
- European Southern Observatory — Astronomers reveal first image of the black hole at the heart of our galaxy (Sagittarius A*)
- Touboul et al., Physical Review Letters 129, 121102 (2022) — MICROSCOPE mission final results