Theories · 1916 – 1937

Gravitational Waves

Einstein predicted ripples in spacetime in 1916, doubted them in 1936, and thought they would never be detected. A century later they were.

★ Worldline Passport (+25 XP)
h=ΔLL

The Prediction

Within months of completing general relativity, Einstein found that his equations allowed disturbances in the geometry of spacetime to travel outward at the speed of light, much as an accelerating electric charge sends out light. He published the idea in June 1916 and returned to it in a second paper in 1918, correcting a mathematical slip in the first paper and deriving the quadrupole formula for the power radiated by an accelerating mass distribution.

A passing gravitational wave stretches space in one direction while squeezing it in the perpendicular direction, then reverses. Its strength is the strain h=ΔL/L: the fractional change in a reference length L. For any source we could hope to observe, the strain is fantastically small, and Einstein doubted the effect would ever be measured.

The Doubt

In 1936, by then in Princeton, Einstein and his assistant Nathan Rosen wrote a paper claiming to prove that plane gravitational waves do not exist without singularities. They submitted it to the Physical Review. The journal sent it to an anonymous referee, who found that the apparent singularities were merely an artifact of the coordinate system they had chosen.

Einstein was not used to peer review. He withdrew the paper in irritation and, apart from one letter to the editor in 1952, never published in that journal again. But the referee, later identified as the cosmologist Howard Percy Robertson, was right. Before the paper appeared in the Journal of the Franklin Institute in 1937, Robertson had quietly shown how to cast the solution in cylindrical coordinates to Einstein's new assistant Leopold Infeld, who passed it on. Einstein, by Infeld's account, had just found a mistake himself. He rewrote the conclusion. The published version describes cylindrical waves that do exist.

The physics community only settled the question in 1957, less than two years after his death, at a conference in Chapel Hill where Richard Feynman and Hermann Bondi introduced the sticky-bead argument: a passing gravitational wave would slide beads back and forth along a rigid rod with friction, heating the rod and proving that gravitational waves carry real physical energy.

The Detection

On 14 September 2015 the two detectors of the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO), in Washington State and Louisiana, recorded the same signal seven milliseconds apart (event GW150914). Two black holes, about 36 and 29 times the mass of the Sun, had spiraled together and merged roughly 1.3 billion light-years away. In the final fraction of a second, about three Suns' worth of mass was converted into gravitational waves.

The detectors are L-shaped, with arms L=4 km long. Their peak strain sensitivity reaches down to h∼10−22—a change in arm length of about one ten-thousandth of the width of a proton—while the first detected wave, GW150914, had a peak strain of h≈10−21, shifting the 4 km arms by ΔL≈4×10−18 m (roughly 1/200 to 1/400 of a proton's diameter).

Rainer Weiss, Barry Barish, and Kip Thorne received the 2017 Nobel Prize in Physics for the detection.

Where It Stands

Gravitational waves are now an everyday observing tool. In August 2017 detectors caught two neutron stars colliding (GW170817), and telescopes around the world saw the flash that followed, the first event observed in both gravity and light. By 2025, across four observing runs with Virgo and KAGRA, the network had cataloged roughly 300 compact binary mergers—including high-precision events such as GW250114 that test Hawking's black-hole area theorem. See Gravitational-Wave Astronomy.

Sources

  1. LIGO — detection of GW150914
  2. LIGO — facts
  3. LIGO — GW170817 press release
  4. Kennefick, Physics Today — Einstein versus the Physical Review
  5. Nobel Prize in Physics 2017 — press release
  6. LIGO — What are gravitational waves?
  7. Einstein and Rosen, Journal of the Franklin Institute 223, 43 (1937) — On gravitational waves
  8. Rickles and DeWitt (eds.) — The role of gravitation in physics: report from the 1957 Chapel Hill conference (Chapter 27: The Reality of Gravitational Waves)
  9. Bondi, Nature 179, 1072 (1957) — Plane gravitational waves in general relativity
  10. LIGO — 10 years of gravitational-wave astronomy and GW250114